Local Guide: Best Seafood Restaurants on Staten Island

Enjoying the Best Seafood on Staten Island

Author

Adriano Blog
May 14, 2024

Staten Island is known for its stunning waterfront views and a rich selection of seafood restaurants that offer fresh, flavorful dishes. Whether you're craving lobster, clam chowder, or a simple fish fry, Staten Island has something to offer every seafood lover. 

My wife Fernanda and I recently explored some of the best seafood spots on Staten Island, and here's our comprehensive guide to the top places you must visit.

Getting to Staten Island

Location: Staten Island, NY
Hours: Varies by restaurant
Website: nycgo.com

Staten Island is easily accessible by the Staten Island Ferry, buses, and taxis. Many of the best seafood restaurants are located along the waterfront, providing not only delicious meals but also beautiful views.

Top Seafood Restaurants

The Lobster House Joe's

Location: 2150 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306
Hours: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-667-0003
Website: lobsterhousejoes.com

The Lobster House Joe's is a must-visit for lobster lovers 🦞. We enjoyed the Lobster Roll and the Lobster Bisque, both of which were rich in flavor and perfectly cooked. The casual, nautical-themed decor added to the dining experience.

Insider Tip: Try their seafood platter for a bit of everything. The outdoor seating is perfect for a summer meal.

Marina Cafe

Location: 154 Mansion Ave, Staten Island, NY 10308
Hours: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-967-3077
Website: marinacafesiny.com

Marina Cafe offers stunning waterfront views and a delicious seafood menu 🍽️. We loved the Grilled Swordfish and the Shrimp Scampi, both of which were fresh and flavorful. The elegant setting and excellent service made it a standout spot.

Insider Tip: Their brunch menu is fantastic. Be sure to reserve a table by the water for the best views.

Blue

Location: 1115 Richmond Terrace, Staten Island, NY 10310
Hours: 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-273-7777
Website: bluerestaurantny.com

Blue offers a modern take on seafood dishes with a creative twist 🎣. We enjoyed the Seared Scallops and the Seafood Paella, both of which were beautifully presented and packed with flavor. The contemporary decor and lively atmosphere made it a great place for a night out.

Insider Tip: Their cocktails are a must-try. The dessert menu is also excellent.

South Fin Grill

Location: 300 Father Capodanno Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305
Hours: 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-447-7679
Website: southfingrill.com

South Fin Grill offers a stunning beachfront location and a fantastic seafood menu 🌊. We loved the Crab Cakes and the Grilled Salmon, both of which were delicious and well-prepared. The beachside seating and attentive service made it a perfect spot for a relaxing meal.

Insider Tip: Their sunset views are incredible. Arrive early for the best seats.

Jimmy Max

Location: 280 Watchogue Rd, Staten Island, NY 10314
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-983-6715
Website: jimmymax.com

Jimmy Max offers a variety of seafood dishes in a friendly, neighborhood setting 🍤. We enjoyed the Fried Calamari and the Baked Clams, both of which were crispy and flavorful. The casual atmosphere and friendly staff made it a great place for a family meal.

Insider Tip: Their pizza is also fantastic. Check out their daily specials for great deals.

Practical Tips

Getting There: Use the Staten Island Ferry, buses, or taxis to reach these top seafood spots. Many are located along the waterfront, providing beautiful views.

What to Bring: An appetite for fresh seafood, a love for exploring new flavors, and a camera for those Instagram-worthy shots 📸.

Best Time to Visit: Evenings and weekends are the best times for dining out. Arrive early for popular spots to avoid long waits.

Exploring More of Staten Island

While enjoying the finest seafood, take the opportunity to explore more of Staten Island. Here are some nearby attractions and activities:

Best Italian Restaurants in Arthur Avenue: Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in the Bronx. Check out our Arthur Avenue Guide for more details.

Breweries and Wineries on Staten Island: Explore the best local brews and wines. Our Staten Island Guide has all the information you need.

Top Steakhouses in Manhattan: Indulge in the finest steaks the city has to offer. See our Steakhouse Guide for tips.

Best Sushi Restaurants in Manhattan: Discover the top sushi spots in the city. Our Sushi Guide will help you find the best sushi.

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn: Explore the best Italian cuisine in Brooklyn. Our Italian Restaurant Guide has all the information you need.

Tips for Enjoying Seafood on Staten Island

For those visiting seafood spots on Staten Island, here are some essential tips to enhance your experience:

Arrive Early: Popular spots can get crowded quickly. Arriving early ensures you get a good seat and can settle in before the rush.

Try Different Dishes: Staten Island offers a variety of seafood dishes. Be adventurous and try something new.

Enjoy the Atmosphere: Many seafood spots on Staten Island offer a unique ambiance. Take your time and enjoy the surroundings.

Pair with Local Drinks: Great seafood deserves great drinks. Many spots offer excellent local beverages that pair perfectly with their dishes.

Final Thoughts

Staten Island's seafood spots offer a delightful array of dishes, combining fresh flavors with stunning waterfront views. From the rich Lobster Roll at The Lobster House Joe's to the elegant Grilled Swordfish at Marina Cafe, each seafood restaurant provides a unique and enjoyable experience. Our seafood tour was a delicious adventure, showcasing the best of Staten Island's vibrant food scene.

Tips for Exploring New York City

While you’re in New York City, consider visiting these other top attractions:

Reply

or to participate.