Local Guide: Best Pizza Places on Staten Island

Discovering the Best Pizza on Staten Island

Author

Adriano Blog
May 16, 2024

Staten Island is home to some of the best pizza in New York City, offering a range of delicious options that cater to all tastes. 

From classic New York slices to gourmet pies, Staten Island’s pizzerias are known for their quality and flavor. My wife Fernanda and I recently explored some of the best pizza places on Staten Island, and here's our comprehensive guide to the top spots you must visit.

Getting to Staten Island

Location: Staten Island, NY
Hours: Varies by restaurant
Website: nycgo.com

Staten Island is easily accessible by the Staten Island Ferry, buses, and taxis. Many of the best pizza places are located in vibrant neighborhoods, making them easy to reach.

Top Pizza Places

Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern

Location: 524 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-442-9401
Website: deninos.com

Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern is a Staten Island institution known for its thin-crust pizzas 🍕. We loved the Clam Pie and the Sausage Pie, both of which were perfectly cooked and full of flavor. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere made it a great spot for a relaxed meal.

Insider Tip: Try their house-made meatballs as an appetizer. They’re a local favorite.

Joe & Pat's Pizzeria

Location: 1758 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-981-0887
Website: joeandpatsny.com

Joe & Pat's Pizzeria offers a unique twist on the classic New York slice with their thin, crispy crust and sweet tomato sauce 🍽️. We enjoyed the Vodka Pizza and the Margherita Pizza, both of which were delicious. The friendly staff and cozy setting added to the overall experience.

Insider Tip: Their fried calamari is a must-try. It pairs perfectly with any pizza.

Lee's Tavern

Location: 60 Hancock St, Staten Island, NY 10305
Hours: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-667-9749
Website: N/A

Lee's Tavern is a hidden gem known for its bar-style pizza 🍺. We loved the Pepperoni Pizza and the White Clam Pizza, both of which were flavorful and satisfying. The laid-back, pub-like atmosphere made it a perfect spot for a casual meal.

Insider Tip: Arrive early to get a table. This place fills up quickly, especially on weekends.

Pizzeria Giove

Location: 278 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-667-5800
Website: pizzeriagiove.com

Pizzeria Giove offers a variety of creative and gourmet pizzas 🍷. We enjoyed the Truffle Pizza and the Giove Special, both of which were rich in flavor and beautifully presented. The modern decor and excellent service made it a standout spot.

Insider Tip: Their dessert pizzas are a delightful end to your meal. Try the Nutella Pizza for a sweet treat.

Brothers Pizzeria

Location: 750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-447-9280
Website: N/A

Brothers Pizzeria offers classic New York-style pizza that’s been a local favorite for years 🌟. We loved the Sicilian Pizza and the Meat Lover's Pizza, both of which were hearty and delicious. The no-frills setting and quick service made it a great spot for a quick bite.

Insider Tip: Their garlic knots are fantastic. Be sure to order a few as a side.

Practical Tips

Getting There: Use the Staten Island Ferry, buses, or taxis to reach these top pizza spots. Many are located in popular neighborhoods, making them easy to find.

What to Bring: An appetite for delicious pizza, a love for exploring new flavors, and a camera for those Instagram-worthy shots 📸.

Best Time to Visit: Evenings and weekends are the best times for dining out. Arrive early for popular spots to avoid long waits.

Exploring More of Staten Island

While enjoying the finest pizza, take the opportunity to explore more of Staten Island. Here are some nearby attractions and activities:

Best Italian Restaurants in Arthur Avenue: Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in the Bronx. Check out our Arthur Avenue Guide for more details.

Breweries and Wineries on Staten Island: Explore the best local brews and wines. Our Staten Island Guide has all the information you need.

Best Steakhouses in Manhattan: Indulge in the finest steaks the city has to offer. See our Steakhouse Guide for tips.

Best Seafood Restaurants on Staten Island: Discover the top seafood spots on the island. Our Seafood Guide will help you find the best seafood.

Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn: Explore the best Italian cuisine in Brooklyn. Our Italian Restaurant Guide has all the information you need.

Tips for Enjoying Pizza on Staten Island

For those visiting pizza spots on Staten Island, here are some essential tips to enhance your experience:

Arrive Early: Popular spots can get crowded quickly. Arriving early ensures you get a good seat and can settle in before the rush.

Try Different Toppings: Staten Island offers a variety of pizza toppings. Be adventurous and try something new.

Enjoy the Atmosphere: Many pizza spots on Staten Island offer a unique ambiance. Take your time and enjoy the surroundings.

Pair with Local Drinks: Great pizza deserves great drinks. Many spots offer excellent local beverages that pair perfectly with their pizzas.

Final Thoughts

Staten Island's pizza spots offer a delightful array of dishes, combining classic flavors with modern twists. From the crispy Clam Pie at Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern to the creative Truffle Pizza at Pizzeria Giove, each pizzeria provides a unique and enjoyable experience. Our pizza tour was a delicious adventure, showcasing the best of Staten Island's vibrant food scene.

Tips for Exploring New York City

While you’re in New York City, consider visiting these other top attractions:

Reply

or to participate.