Local Guide: Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn

Exploring the Finest Italian Cuisine in Brooklyn

Author

Adriano Blog
May 30, 2024

Brooklyn is a treasure trove of culinary delights, especially when it comes to Italian cuisine. 

From classic red-sauce joints to modern Italian bistros, the borough offers a diverse array of Italian restaurants that cater to every palate.

My wife Fernanda and I recently explored some of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, and here's our comprehensive guide to the top spots you must try.

Getting to Brooklyn

Location: Brooklyn, NY
Hours: Varies by restaurant
Website: nycgo.com

Brooklyn is easily accessible by public transportation, including the subway, buses, and taxis. Many Italian restaurants are located in popular neighborhoods, making them easy to visit.

Top Italian Restaurants

Lucali

Location: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Hours: 5:45 PM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-858-4086
Website: lucali.com

Lucali is a legendary pizza spot in Brooklyn known for its delicious, thin-crust pies 🍕. We enjoyed the classic Margherita pizza and the calzone, both of which were perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. The cozy, candlelit atmosphere added to the charm.

Insider Tip: Arrive early to secure a spot, as Lucali doesn't take reservations and there is often a long wait. Bring cash, as they do not accept credit cards.

Lilia

Location: 567 Union Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Hours: 5:30 PM - 10:30 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-576-3095
Website: lilianewyork.com

Lilia offers a modern take on Italian cuisine, with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients 🍝. We loved the Cacio e Pepe Frittelle and the Agnolotti, both of which were exquisite. The sleek, stylish decor and friendly service made our dining experience exceptional.

Insider Tip: Make a reservation well in advance, as Lilia is very popular. Try their house-made pasta for a true taste of Italy.

Roberta's

Location: 261 Moore St, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Hours: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-417-1118
Website: robertaspizza.com

Roberta's is a hip, bustling pizzeria and Italian restaurant known for its inventive pizzas and rustic dishes 🍕. We enjoyed the Bee Sting pizza and the homemade pastas, all of which were delicious. The lively, eclectic atmosphere added to the fun.

Insider Tip: Don't miss their outdoor seating area, which is perfect for a casual meal. Their bakery also offers some fantastic bread and pastries.

Al Di La Trattoria

Location: 248 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Hours: 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM (Tue-Sun), Closed (Mon)
Phone: +1 718-783-4565
Website: aldilatrattoria.com

Al Di La Trattoria is a beloved neighborhood restaurant offering traditional Venetian dishes in a charming, rustic setting 🍷. We savored the Ragu alla Bolognese and the Black Spaghetti, both of which were flavorful and authentic. The warm, welcoming vibe made us feel right at home.

Insider Tip: They don't take reservations, so try to visit during off-peak hours to avoid a long wait. Their wine list is excellent, so be sure to ask for recommendations.

Frankies 457 Spuntino

Location: 457 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Hours: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM (Mon-Sun)
Phone: +1 718-403-0033
Website: frankiesspuntino.com

Frankies 457 Spuntino offers a cozy, casual dining experience with a focus on simple, high-quality Italian dishes 🍝. We loved the Meatball Sandwich and the Cavatelli with Faiccos Sausage, both of which were hearty and satisfying. The outdoor garden seating is a lovely touch.

Insider Tip: This is a great spot for brunch, so consider visiting on the weekend. Their homemade olive oil cake is a must-try.

Practical Tips

Getting There: Use the subway, buses, or taxis to reach these top Italian restaurants. Many are located in popular neighborhoods, making them easy to find.

What to Bring: An appetite, a love for Italian cuisine, and a willingness to explore new flavors 🍝. Reservations are recommended for most spots, especially on weekends.

Best Time to Visit: Evenings are the best time for a cozy Italian dinner. Arrive early for lunch or brunch to avoid the crowds.

Exploring More of Brooklyn

While enjoying the finest Italian cuisine, take the opportunity to explore more of Brooklyn. Here are some nearby attractions and activities:

Best Italian Restaurants in Arthur Avenue: Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in the Bronx. Check out our Arthur Avenue Guide for more details.

Breweries and Wineries on Staten Island: Explore the best local brews and wines. Our Staten Island Guide has all the information you need.

Top Steakhouses in Manhattan: Indulge in the finest steaks the city has to offer. See our Steakhouse Guide for tips.

Best Sushi Restaurants in Manhattan: Discover the top sushi spots in the city. Our Sushi Guide will help you find the best sushi.

Hidden Speakeasies in Manhattan: Uncover the secret bars and unique cocktails of the city. Check out our Speakeasy Guide for a night of adventure.

Tips for Enjoying Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn

For those visiting Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, here are some essential tips to enhance your experience:

Make Reservations: Many popular Italian restaurants can get crowded, so making a reservation in advance is a good idea.

Ask for Recommendations: Don’t hesitate to ask the staff for their recommendations. They can often guide you to the best dishes on the menu.

Pair with Wine: Italian cuisine pairs wonderfully with wine. Ask for wine pairing suggestions to elevate your meal.

Explore Different Dishes: While pasta and pizza are staples, don't shy away from trying other Italian dishes like seafood and antipasti.

Final Thoughts

Brooklyn's Italian restaurants offer a delightful array of dishes, combining traditional flavors with modern twists. From the iconic pizzas at Lucali to the exquisite pasta at Lilia, each restaurant provides a unique and delicious experience. Our Italian restaurant tour was a culinary delight, showcasing the best of Brooklyn's vibrant food scene.

Tips for Exploring New York City

While you’re in New York City, consider visiting these other top attractions:

Reply

or to participate.